Den of Geek

Star Trek: The Original Series episode 22 review

Mark Pickavance


How does Space Seed fare in our retrospective look at Star Trek's original series, now in high definition?

Published on May 26, 2009

Episode: 22
Title: Space Seed
Star Date: 3141.9
Writer: Gene L. Coon
First Shown: 16th February 1967

In the original series, some episodes are so good that they entirely changed the Star Trek mythology and Space Seed is certainly in that group. It's a relatively simple story, but presented in a very tight way that elevates the characters and their ambitions. Written by Gene L. Coon, prolific writer and producer for the show, it extrapolates what might happen if a historical character and dictator was deposited through time onto the Enterprise, and how the crew might react to him.

In deep space the Enterprise encounters a derelict ship, the US Botany Bay, originally launched in the 20th century. The ship's name is something of a subtle warning, but no one on the Enterprise seems to get the hint. On the Botany Bay are passengers frozen in cryogenic suspension, one of those being Khan Noonien Singh. He's a genetically engineered super-human, who was an infamous tyrant from Earth history. Evidently, during the late twentieth century in Trek lore, a Eugenics war is raging, and Khan and his allies are remnants of this period.

Being smart, devious and very strong Khan soon realises that if he can defrost the other super-soldiers on the Botany Bay then he'll be able to take control of the Enterprise and rule the universe, quadrant, whatever. But he starts by entrancing the lovely Lt. McGivers, who soon falls for his direct approach and lethal charm.

Soon he's controlling life support to kill all those on the bridge, and throws Kirk into a decompression chamber in an attempt to get him to instruct the crew to follow his orders.

Where this goes from just being Kirk trying to stop a madman to something more spectacular is in the portrayal of Kahn by the expressive Ricardo Montalbán. He gives Kahn plenty of passion and energy, and not a little degree of swagger. In many respects he's a dark version of Kirk, and they share the overconfidence that will ultimately be his undoing.

Kirk stops Khan taking the Enterprise, and decides to maroon him and his crew on the then lush world of Ceti Alpha V. This turns out to be a really bad plan, as 15 years later Khan escapes that now desert world and comes looking for Kirk and more than a little revenge. Spock even says prophetically in this episode, "It would be interesting, Captain, to return to that world in a hundred years, and learn what crop had sprung from the seed you planted today."

The strengths of this episode stand out on reviewing, and it seems now an entirely obvious choice for great source material for the second and best original cast film outing in Wrath Of Khan. The only bizarre thing I noticed was that in that film Chekov is recognised by Khan, which is odd because he's not a TOS season one character and as such they're never seen to meet. That minor plot hole aside, Space Seed created some wonderful unfinished business that the original series never addressed, but Wrath Of Khan immortalised.

The remastering work done on this work isn't major, although they've made the Botany Bay a more believable vessel.

The next review is another favourite of mine, the frighteningly logical A Taste Of Armageddon.

 

Users Comments

Re: Star Trek: The Original Series episode 22 review
Posted By etoh76 1 May 26, 2009 11:21:04 AM

The Chekov plothole - I heard from somewhere that the answer to this was that even though Chekov wasn't on the bridge he was still stationed elsewhere on the ship. As Khan had access to and reviewed the Enterprise's records for "educational" purposes he probably came across Chekov's personnel file as a crewman aboard the Enterprise. Works for me!

Re: Star Trek: The Original Series episode 22 review
Posted By ON3i1 1 May 28, 2009 01:22:52 AM

As much as I enjoy your reviews, Mark, I must take exception when you say this episode "changed the Star Trek mythology." When Nick Meyer brought back Khan for the 1982 film, I remember it being a rather unexpected choice. In other words, the original episode was seen as quite good, but hardly a standout. Thus, the "importance" of this episode was only established retroactively, In fact, it'd assert that it was BECAUSE the original episode was not so well known that the Chekov problem arose. People in general (and Mr. Meyer in particular) couldn't easily remember that he wasn't around.

Re: Star Trek: The Original Series episode 22 review
Posted By hammer 1 December 9, 2009 09:25:58 PM

A charismatic performance by the terrific Ricardo Montalban.Trivia:Montalban & Madlyn Rhue(Marla McGivers)played husband & wife on an episode of Bonanza several years prior to Space Seed.
Post a Comment
 
ST: TOS episode 22

Star Trek: TOS episode 22 Space Seed

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Broadband

Mobile Broadband

Compare over 100 mobile broadband & broadband deals online!

Mobile Phones

LG ArenaHTC Magic

Compare over 250 mobile phones &
52,000 deals!

Click Here