Doctor Who: the assistant survival odds

Simon Brew


Will a Doctor Who assistant meet their maker in Journey's End? We assess the survival chances of Rose, Donna, Martha, Sarah-Jane and the Torchwood team...

Not long to go now before the final episode of this series of Doctor Who airs, and we finally get answers to the questions that we’ve been posing all week. But there’s still one we’ve not fully taken a look at, and that’s which of the assistants is likely to be gone be the end of the series.

Here are our odds for who’s likely to meet their maker come the end of Saturday’s episode. We’re, er, not taking bets though…

DONNA (Catherine Tate)
1/2 (favourite)

The whole series has been pointing to some kind of sacrifice for Donna, and we’re actually already seen her die in Turn Left. Rose has told her that she won’t survive, an River Song, way back in Forest Of The Dead, wasn’t too hot on her survival chances either.

Furthermore, The Shadow Proclamation have told her that she’s facing a big loss. While that might be her Grandfather, the pointers are still firmly heading in her direction.

Yet that might be precisely the reason why she doesn’t die. There are all sorts of theories about Donna right now. Could she be The Master? Why is the bug still seemingly on her back? Is she on the Doctor’s side or not?

ROSE (Billie Piper)

Evens

If Russell T Davies wanted to pull the rug a little, and he’s done it several times before, then Rose Tyler could be for the chop. All those longing looks as all the companions were visible on the laptop screen in The Stolen Earth but her. Then the longing looks at the Doctor. Then the running from opposite ends of the street to meet up. Then the huge upset that the Doctor was regenerating.

So: has RTD just bought Rose back to kill her off? She’s certainly a strong candidate, not least because if, as some suspect, Catherine Tate gets turned in some way in this last episode and a twist was to be pulled, the light surely would shine in Rose’s face double quick. Across the four series that Russell T Davies has been in charge, she’s been the most prominent companion, and seemingly the one that the Doctor is the fondest of (he did, after all, spend much of series three pining for her). Would the death of Rose hurt him most of all? That’s surely one reason why she’s such a strong candidate for the proverbial bullet…

MARTHA (Freema Agyeman)
8/1

Martha is unlikely to be meeting her maker, primarily because she doesn’t really fit the criteria here. She’s not really the most faithful companion, after all. The one factor that raises the possibility of her going out in a blaze of glory is the Osterhagen Key, that she’s been given custody of. If this is, as some suspect, a method by which one person can sacrifice themselves and save the Universe, then she is currently holding it in her hands. That makes her a candidate, but not a very likely one.

CAPTAIN JACK (John Barrowman)
15/1

‘Everlasting death for the most faithful companion’ was the prophecy from Dalek Caan, and that surely on one or two levels rules out Captain Jack. That said, the only thing that puts him in the firing line is the word ‘everlasting’. It’s already been established that you don’t kill Captain Jack – at least not until he’s a big face in a jar – but the one threat that could work against him is that of being killed repeatedly over and over. Is that everlasting death? Sure sounds like it to us. There’s the small matter of the next series of Torchwood, though…

NO ONE WILL DIE
15/1

Don’t totally write this one off. Doctor Who has found many ways in the past of allowing characters to suffer horrible fates but not actually buy it, and this may be the case again here. There are enough parallel universes to dump people into, where they can be sealed forever, after all. And what odds, incidentally, should we offer on two people going? Hmmm...

SARAH-JANE SMITH (Elisabeth Sladen)
100/1

Surely, with a spin-off series and an enduring legacy in the show, this isn’t Sarah-Jane’s time to check out of Doctor Who? Even though we see her face to face with a pair of Daleks at the end of The Stolen Earth, it says everything that that’s the bit of the cliffhanger that virtually nobody is focusing on, simply because nobody’s in any doubt she’ll get out of it.

That said, there’s little doubt that Sarah-Jane could qualify as ‘the most faithful companion’. But they wouldn’t, would they? We think it very, very unlikely.

GWEN & IANTO (Eve Myles & Gareth David-Lloyd)
150/1

Much though it’s been fun to have this pair in Doctor Who, neither has been brought along to be killed off. There’s the ongoing Torchwood spin-off, there’s the fact that if anyone from Torchwood is going then it’s Captain Jack, and there’s the fact that they aren’t the Doctor’s companions.

K9
1000/1

Er, he’s a dog, and he’s faithful. He’s not in the episode, which could prove to be a hindrance. Plus, even he’s got a bleedin’ spin-off series in the works…

Share your thoughts, and place your (not real) bets in the Comments below...

Check out the new and ever growing Doctor Who page at DoG, where we are marshalling all the Who content at the site, including interviews, DVD and episode reviews, lists, opinions and articles on our favourite time traveller. 

 

User's Comments

Re: Doctor Who: the assistant survival odds
Posted by Malky on July 3, 2008 09:45:15 AM

Rose can not die, that'll break my little heart. Although she may volunteer to absorb the time stream again to save the earth. I have a suspicion that the time stream will come into again.

Re: Doctor Who: the assistant survival odds
Posted by windymiller on July 3, 2008 09:59:36 AM

You forgot to mention the TARDIS. Surely the most faithful companion of all.

Re: Doctor Who: the assistant survival odds
Posted by twinboom on July 3, 2008 10:14:01 AM

Maybe it means the hand in the jar, or who/what the regeneration turns it into. As all us geeks know, your hand can be your most faithful companion, and the doctor has spent a lot of time on his own in the Tardis...!

Re: Doctor Who: the assistant survival odds
Posted by Malky on July 3, 2008 01:09:24 PM

The tardis cant die it swould permanently limit the scope of the series. imagine the doctor gets a bus to london from birmingham to stop alien invasion, it would not work.

Re: Doctor Who: the assistant survival odds
Posted by emilychap89 on July 3, 2008 02:22:33 PM

the only way the tardis could die would to be change appearance, it was said early in the 1st serise and a couple of times in the old dr who,s that it was stuck in the form of a police box but i majorly dout it, its to much of a big symbol of the show i dont think it will be donna, even the dr said its as if they have some special link

Re: Doctor Who: the assistant survival odds
Posted by fishfish on July 3, 2008 09:55:40 PM

Tbh i think something might happen to donna i dont think she will die but something will happen to her as the last few episodes have been mentioning little things about her!!!!

Re: Doctor Who: the assistant survival odds
Posted by theresa on July 4, 2008 12:17:33 AM

This is going to sound so harsh, but I think it almost has to be Rose. I like Rose, but storywise, at this point, her existence is a problem. The Doctor can't marry and settle down and have little Doctors running around the TARDIS. If this is what it's going to be, it won't be Doctor Who anymore. So, close your eyes and think of this: Rose as Jenny's stepmom.

Re: Doctor Who: the assistant survival odds
Posted by Killer7 on July 4, 2008 12:45:59 PM

I really don't know what's going to happen, and to be honest, all theories are possible here. I think the whole Donna/Master theory is interesting though, and the beeps on former PM Jones' network were unmistakably the same sequence as the Master's drums. But I suspect any reappearance of the Master will be saved for another series. Davros is surely enough of a foe for one episode...

Although I'd hate to see it, as it'd be really poor and hugely Deus Ex Machina, there's always the Doctor's Daughter who could buy it. She did, after all, save his life (well, stopped him getting shot anyway) by jumping in front of him and taking a bullet. That's pretty faithful. But is she a 'companion'?

I'd personally agree that Rose is the most likely candidate though. Donna just seems to be too obvious as collateral damage, with big ol' neon signs pointing to her demise or loss. While Rose is surely heading for closure in the Dr Who canon.

Not long to wait now though.

Re: Doctor Who: the assistant survival odds
Posted by GwendolynFelton on July 4, 2008 03:08:50 PM

As much as I love Rose I just can't see her surviving this last episode. Yes, she's been through so much to travel through universes to find the Doctor but I feel as if her time has run out. I know Rose and the Doctor had a closer relationship but I can't see that happening forever. Captain Jack and Sarah Jane Smith both have shows outside of Doctor Who and I can't see RTD killing off someone from another show in this show..lol. It's possible but not probably since some people that watch Torchwood or SJA may not watch Doctor Who. How would it look for a new season of Torchwood or SJA to come on only to find out that Sarah Jane had been exterminated or Captain Jack to be sentenced to death forever? Riversong never actually said that Donna was not around, although she didn't seem to know who she was immediately. Keep in mind though that Riversong is from the future and although the Doctor can timetravel maybe Donna simply stepped down as the Doctor's companion. The look on Riversong's face looked something of disbelief instead of dread...not the normal look you'd give someone that just simply wasn't alive later on. I can't even begin to imagine what Donna is though...the Master? Another time-lord in disguise? The only issue I have with her being the Master or someone in disguise is that she has a family. From what we've seen so far with the Master and the Doctor both when they go "into hiding" is that they don't know anyone from the "other world". Like the Doctor had Martha, though, they can take people with them but it seems as if they have to start their life anew when they become human. Donna could possibly be someone in hiding but my suspicions are that she'll just do something incredible to save the world. Martha - I can see her dying but only because the key won't work properly (although we still don't know what the key does). So far she hasn't had much interaction with the Daleks so her departure doesn't seem as imminent as much as everyone elses.

Re: Doctor Who: the assistant survival odds
Posted by doctorwhogemma on July 4, 2008 06:30:21 PM

eerrrmmmm.....the time beetle isnt on donnas back anymore "there was something on your back" is past tense (isnt it?) :) anyways i hope sarah jane doesnt die (i know there is little chance of her dying) but she is quite amazing and i love her to bits :D *gemma* (#1 dw fan)

Re: Doctor Who: the assistant survival odds
Posted by RusselD on July 6, 2008 01:28:16 AM

Looks like you were wrong about K9 not being in the episode ;) Anyway, I apologise for the state of this episode. It didn't turn out as I was planning and I'm not pleased with it. I had a great time working on Dr Who though, really enjoyed myself.
Post a comment
 
The logo for Doctor Who.
Doctor Who: place your bets...
Related Articles

Search

Den of Geek. Shortlisted for the Launch of the Year 2008 by the British Society of Magazine Editors

© Dennis Publishing 2008