Den of Geek

Doctor Who Silence in the Library: a ratings flop?

Simon Brew


The ratings are in for last weekend's excellent Doctor Who episode. And it seems most of Britain wanted Ant and Dec instead...

Published on Jun 4, 2008

Ready to be depressed? Last Saturday night, the BBC broadcast a terrific slice of science fiction television, and by common consensus, the best episode of Doctor Who thus far this year. Silence In The Library – and you can read our thoughts on it here – was everything you could realistically want from the best part of an hour on a Saturday night.

Silence In The Library
also gave Doctor Who its worst ratings of the year, as the programme – for the first time since it returned to the airwaves in 2005 – wasn’t even the most popular programme at the time it was being shown. 5.4 million viewers tuned in to see the programme, just over a quarter of the viewing audience at the time.

So what was everyone watching instead? What programmes were on that could have possibly eclipsed Doctor Who for quality, entertainment and Saturday night joy?

Britain’s Got fecking Talent.

ITV’s juggernaut hit 13 million viewers at its peak, and easily won the battle to be the most popular programme of the night. Also competing against the BBC’s own vacuous talent contest, I’d Do Anything, Doctor Who came in fifth for the day, and just scraped into the top 30 for the week.

If that’s what people choose to watch, then perhaps the schedules should just be a rolling programme of Coronation Street, EastEnders, Holby and reality TV shows. Oh, hang on…

 

Users Comments

Re: Doctor Who Silence in the Library: a ratings flop?
Posted By Ian_Osborne 1 June 4, 2008 10:32:28 AM

It will be interesting to see what Sunday's BBC3 repeat does for that week. I reckon with the Eurovision-enforced week off the previous weekend, people simply forgot to tune in, and went for the Sunday repeat instead.

Re: Doctor Who Silence in the Library: a ratings flop?
Posted By RonHogan 1 June 4, 2008 01:07:42 PM

Welcome to the future of television.

Re: Doctor Who Silence in the Library: a ratings flop?
Posted By stuxmusic 1 June 4, 2008 01:13:14 PM

We all know that people with brains watch stuff like Discovery, History etc, and in their spare time, Doctor Who. We also know that bad people watch the majority of programes that ITV has to offer. We also know that I watch Doctor Who, and it was awesome. It really got me to thinking, best episode of who in the past 4 seasons? [I say specifically new who because I've not seen anything previous]

Re: Doctor Who Silence in the Library: a ratings flop?
Posted By WeakLemonDrink 1 June 4, 2008 01:35:08 PM

The good news being, of course, that this episode got an Ai of 89%! AND the viewing figures for the BBC repeat were much larger than normal.

Re: Doctor Who Silence in the Library: a ratings flop?
Posted By TVDust1 1 June 4, 2008 03:23:43 PM

B.G.T. has been murdering 'Who all season; isn't that why they moved it back to 7pm, or started it early? I can't remember which. The real danger is that people start taking Who for granted - like they did before. You don't miss yer water, and all that.

Re: Doctor Who Silence in the Library: a ratings flop?
Posted By IAmATVJunkie 1 June 4, 2008 05:09:44 PM

Concurrance from me. I just don't get the talent shows, especially the early rounds. For example, the early eps of American Idol are just an exercise in sado-masochism. And it was such a good episode, how could someone choose Cowell over a Steve Moffat episode?

Re: Doctor Who Silence in the Library: a ratings flop?
Posted By wanderjahre 1 June 5, 2008 07:22:37 AM

Be interested to see what the combined viewing figures the show plus the Sunday and Friday repeats. I suspect some people simply decided to watch the other side knowing they could see it either the following day or Friday or watch it online. The availability of repeats does rather make a mockery of ratings.

Re: Doctor Who Silence in the Library: a ratings flop?
Posted By MadOvid 1 June 6, 2008 05:36:44 AM

It was a good episode. Although I had to watch it through less than legal means since the BBC player doesn't work outside of England. Thanks BBC!! >: P But when it comes to CBC I'll make sure to turn the lights down low and get spooked all over again. And then again when it comes out on DVD.

Re: Doctor Who Silence in the Library: a ratings flop?
Posted By SLOK 1 August 27, 2009 09:49:02 AM

This was a great story. I know what put people off though: the "Next Time..." trailer. I couldn't work out why, but my then Who-buddy instinctively turned her nose up at it. When the episodes aired she had already built up a lot of irrational brick walls against the story, and as a result was unable to sit back and enjoy. I hope the Moff lives up to his own script and obliterates spoilers altogether.
Post a Comment
 
So just what is going on here? Silence in the living rooms?

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Broadband

Mobile Broadband

Compare over 100 mobile broadband & broadband deals online!

Mobile Phones

LG ArenaHTC Magic

Compare over 250 mobile phones &
52,000 deals!

Click Here