Den of Geek

The Day Of The Triffids episode 2 review

Mark Pickavance


Mark tries a second helping of this latest incarnation of the classic sci-fi tale in the concluding episode of The Day Of The Triffids…

Published on Dec 30, 2009

My review of the first night certainly divided people neatly into those willing to give the second half a chance and those who thought I should re-read the book. If I gave the impression that this new version was taken from John Wyndham's 1951 novel verbatim, I apologise, because what I meant to convey was that characters and events are broadly common, although exactly what happens is substantially different. But then this is true of all the versions produced so far, so that's not especially interesting.

Having now seen the first half again on HD and not a poor DVD transfer, I can also agree with those who thought the Triffids weren't the strongest aspect of this production. But I stand by my assertion that, in general, the first half was entertaining, and I was genuinely interested to see where the second half took us.

Part two started with the lightweight cliffhanger of Masen and Coker surrounded by Triffids in the dark, dark woods. Which was resolved by Masen directing the Triffids to Torrence's henchman with his Gameboy-inspired MP3 player. Soon they're back in the truck that brought them trimming down those plants with no road sense. At this point, shown a simple and effective way of reducing Triffid numbers, I wanted them to find a big industrial farm, enter the barn where the A-Team music would start before the doors swung open to reveal the world's first armoured combine harvester, before they unleashed some agricultural carnage! But, alas, instead they end up finding their way to a nunnery run by the strident Mother Superior Durrant, played by Vanessa Redgrave.

This interlude was relatively short and sweet as it's obvious from the outset that the convent's lack of attacking Triffids isn't bestowed by divine intervention. The sacrificial relationship that's grown up here hints at the level of intelligence that the Triffids now have, as do a few other scenes later on, but their problem solving and communication isn't something that's truly explored.

What this part of the story did do, though, was get me much more into the Masen character, and Dougray Scott certainly made the most of the scene where he returns to confront Durrant after finding the body of the old man in the wood.

Meanwhile back in London, Jo is still the 'voice of Britain', although I noticed that they've still not put any advertising between her announcements. She was told that Bill is dead, and then she's told that Coker is dead and begins to smell a rat.

Torrence finds her attractive, which only adds to her complications and encourages her eventual escape. The most remarkable aspect of her fleeing London is that she chooses to do it in the most unsuitable vehicle imaginable, a SMART! OK, I accept that's what the Chinese restaurant owner had, but surely in her journey she must have seen tens of thousands of abandoned vehicles more suitable than a SMART. But I digress.

Bill leaves the convent and heads towards his father, who might hold the key to stopping the Triffids. But he runs into Susan and her sister Imogen, young survivalists armed to the teeth. How lethally equipped they are seems to be an intentional piece of humour, although Masen is lucky to be alive to team up with them after they spot him first. There's an underlying theme here which I think the book also contained about family, as Bill assembles his in this curious ad-hoc fashion rather than by the usual methods.

Eventually, Bill and Jo meet up with Dennis Masen and it's an idyllic scene with the period cottage surrounded by high voltage cables and even a pet Triffid in the back.

In the first episode, I'd suggested that the dialogue was good, but in the second outing it wasn't as strong, as represented by Bill's meeting with Dennis.

Dennis, played by Brian Cox, greets his so with the amazing line, "So...you're here about the Triffids?" No,Dennis, he's come to borrow a cup of sugar! Cox rather phones his performance in here, but then, given lines like that I can't entirely blame him.

Dennis has already hatched a plan to subtly scupper the Triffids by getting a female to spawn infertile offspring, for which he needs a male sexual organ that Bill must get for him. I had two problems with this entire sequence, the first being that due to the electric fence, I could see no plausible way that Susan stows away in the Range Rover without anyone seeing her, and that after what Bill does to the chosen plant it's of any use to anyone. Do they jump the shark? No, they jump the Triffid, after assaulting it with a double barrelled shotgun and a light machine gun.

With their plan coming to fruition there's only one possible way this can go, which is with Dennis getting careless with the female Triffid while playing the sound recordings of the plants that his wife recorded in Kenya.

How much is made of these sounds and what they might mean is given a good amount of running time in both nights, but actually at the end we're none the wiser about what the sounds represent or why they agitate the current Triffids. The only purpose they provide is as a distraction in both the end of night one and the climax of the story on night two.

Annoyed that she's stood him up on their dinner date, and realising that Masen might be more important that he realised when he tried to have him killed, Torrence turns up at Dennis' cottage so that Izzard can hone his most manic acting. I recall this scene in both the book and the 1962 movie, and both are entirely different to what happens here.

Using the now repaired MP3 player, Susan attracts all the local Triffids so that they surround the complex. Now, in general, I hated the movie, but in one respect their line-up of Triffids was much more impressive than the one we see here, where the dark is used to mask how many are out there. But then there isn't a petrol tanker handle to burn through these, so you're left wondering how anyone will survive.

The answer (and we had at least six or seven flashbacks as hints) is the wooden mask that Bill keeps remembering. Amazingly, he's known all along how to survive with Triffids, as the 'ritual' was performed on him as a boy. The mask allows the Triffid poison to be placed only on the eyes, which then immunises the recipient against Triffid attack. Did I buy this rather farfetched answer? Not entirely. It does rather assume you can overcome one Triffid to perform the trick, which is like saying you'll be safe from muggers if you can get the knife off the first one you encounter.

Torrence gets what he's deserved all along, and it ends as per the book with them going off to the Isle of Wight to save humanity as a long-term project.

It all wrapped up rather quickly, and I was actually slightly disappointed there wasn't a third night, really. In the end it was an acceptable adventure with a few thrilling parts and others I'd rather forget. Dougray Scott was much better in the second helping as was Joely Richardson, although I was slightly confused by the strength of their relationship given what little we'd been shown of it in episode one. Izzard didn't really add to what he'd achieved in the first night, and in some respects I liked him more when he was less reactive to events.

In the end, this wasn't a classic Triffids, although it avoided descending into the dramatic abyss some recent BBC drama productions have gone (Bonekickers, Paradox). The Triffids weren't very imaginatively presented and the overall message of living in harmony with nature was somewhat slipped under the door in the last five minutes. I'd give them an A+ for trying, but a B- for what they achieved.

The best recommendation I can give it is that, having established the characters, I was interested to see this continue, where any comparisons with previous productions or the books would, thankfully, be moot.

Read our review of Part One here.

 

Users Comments

Re: The Day Of The Triffids episode 2 review
Posted By cordas2 1 December 30, 2009 01:25:20 PM

I am in 2 minds about this adaptation. On the one hand it wasn't the cluster frak that I feared it might be, although they did tease us with a solution even more improbable than 'spraying them with salt water'. Fortunately however they pulled the gun on that idea in what has to be one of the most poorly handled scenes in the entire show. On the other hand it didn't live up to the quality of the 81 production, it had some new ideas and some of them were well done for the most part. I think that a bit more thought (not a huge amount) could have made this into something great.

Re: The Day Of The Triffids episode 2 review
Posted By bazellis 1 December 30, 2009 02:05:32 PM

Absolutely crap. So many basic quetions that were failed to be addressed. What exactly is the outcome of this, that everyone in the UK has to move to the Isle Of Wight!!? What's wrong with the Isle Of Man, come to that - or the Channel Islands!! What were all the other countries doing about their triffid infestation?? What about all the people in the world that were living in the night when the solar wave happened? Surely if they were meant to have experienced it 12 hours earlier, they would have alerted the other half of the world, or visa versa if they were due to experience it 12 hours later? If their plan to create infertile offsping had worked, wouldn't this have created at least a whole new strain of triffids which the human race would've had to have put up with until they died out. How long would this have taken - a few months if they're like any other plant!! Very, very poorly written adaptation.

Re: The Day Of The Triffids episode 2 review
Posted By cordas2 1 December 30, 2009 03:04:11 PM

No not everyone has to move to Isle of Wight, only those who are a) alive b) can see to read the notice c) have the leaflet dropped on them d) can travel e) survive the journey. As for the other islands, nothing wrong with them but in the book it was the Isle of Wight and the script writer saw no need to change it (in the novel they also mention that other communities are growing on the Channel Islands). As for what other countries where doing who cares? The story told is the survival of a handful of people from London, not the entire race (you do understand the idea that in order to tell a story you have to have a manageable number of cast members). As for the Solar wave who knows how the 'night' side of the planet was affected... we weren't shown, maybe the wave washed around and blinded some/most/nearly everyone... As for the solution, you are right it wasn't a 'miracle kill every triffid on the planet fix' however it would have been a better solution than none at all.

Re: The Day Of The Triffids episode 2 review
Posted By bigal65 1 December 30, 2009 04:03:19 PM

It was enjoyable enough hokum, but why everyone thought that shooting the Triffids with guns was a good way to despatch them I don't understand? Surely a few flamethrowers would have got rid of them quick enough, or failing that a few vans driven at high speed seemed a good way to kill off a few, as despite their high IQ, the Triffids had no sense of the Green Cross Code, and were squashed on a number of occasions. And what was with that 'poison in the eyes' rubbish as a way of escaping them? And a lot of the blind people seemed to have conveniently vanished from the UK come the third day of the disaster, I presume the good ole US of A, (who is normally the only country that can survive and ward off such disasters whilst the rest of the world flounders), para-dropped thousands of guide dogs thus solving one problem? The acting was on the whole good, but I think it could have been much better.

Re: The Day Of The Triffids episode 2 review
Posted By bazellis 1 December 30, 2009 04:19:03 PM

cordas2 - My whole winge relates to the fact that there was no clear ending or closure to this, for what was a stand-alone 2 part drama. Ignore the fact that this was based on a novel (I'm sure the majority of the audience have'nt read it) What was the outcome of this? That the triffids carry on the domination of the planet, except for those countries/islands that are very close to the sea?

Re: The Day Of The Triffids episode 2 review
Posted By cordas2 1 December 30, 2009 04:33:05 PM

Who knows, maybe the BBC will follow it up with a series? Personally it bugs the crap out of me that so many 'apocalypses' have a happy ending where just in time the hero finds a magical dohickey to save the world at the last minute. Give me an ambiguous ending every time over such trite garbage. As for the original novel, go find a copy of it its even now a really good read (better than the TV show by a good margin).

Re: The Day Of The Triffids episode 2 review
Posted By madforit89 1 December 30, 2009 11:57:26 PM

Overall the CGI was cheap. They modified the triffid appediture that strikes you to have a small end. in the 81 version you knew about it when you got hit in the face! Where has all the suspence gone from that version too! overall it all felt rushed, you never really felt the global catostrophy you hear about. Very bitty. When they storm the garage at the military HQ, a couple of tear gas cans and 3 pensioners rush in. everyones captured and off we go. the army dont storm the garge and retraliate. Also where are the army from that seen on. Never heard of again. It's all rather blinkered. Yes where to next. Do we wait untill xmas 2010. Or will it be another expensive BBC hash that wont make it to the cutting table for a second season! all said and done it's still a better piece of cinematography than most contrived works of US, that we get spoon fed. so I hope it will be back - learning from mistakes and looking better!

Re: The Day Of The Triffids episode 2 review
Posted By daevouk 1 January 1, 2010 11:01:00 AM

One of the problems was that Coker's unseen/untold story seemed more interesting than that of the so called hero. What happened after he left the convent? i.e.how he managed to fight his way across country and find out about the Isle of W sanctuary.

The Day Of The Triffids episode 2 review
Posted By keith.perry@sky.com 1 January 1, 2010 09:56:28 PM

The most excited I can get about this mini series is "it was ok." It bore little relationship with John Wyndham's novel and totally misses the main point of the book i.e. the struggle for survival. The novel played much importance on the struggle for survival and the problems that any survivors of a holocaust would have to deal with. The Triffids were of secondary importance. Let's face it there was no mention of the disease in the 2009 series, and this was fundamental to the reason why Bill and Josella and others left London. The 1981 TV series came closest to the novel but even that missed out huge chunks. I can only hope that one day somebody will produce a TV series that portrays The Day of the Triffids as John Wyndham had intended.

Re: The Day Of The Triffids episode 2 review
Posted By essjayar 1 January 1, 2010 10:25:03 PM

Yep, great stuff, although flawed. This was an adaptation of the classic novel and I for one am glad it didn't stick to the written word religously. It's been done before, after all! I don't know what the ratings were like but continued success will mean the Beeb will keep bringing us great SciFi and Fantasy fare :-D

Re: The Day Of The Triffids episode 2 review
Posted By Omniaural 1 January 2, 2010 09:55:19 PM

I can understand fans of the book and the 80's series not being happy with this but I was fairly happy with it. It's not a classic, but it offered a good evening's entertainment. Maybe there's an argument as to whether the BBC should be producing specials like this without some kind of unique take. Perhaps they should be looking to adapt more recent material rather than going back to the same old stories time and again as they do with their period stuff. Something more inventive like Will Self's Book of Dave or Robert Rankin's wealth of material.

Re: The Day Of The Triffids episode 2 review
Posted By cordas2 1 January 3, 2010 03:29:06 PM

I dunno there is something timeless about DotT, yes it has been done before (and better) but the basic tale has probably never been more relevant, although it will grow more relevant I feel in the coming decades. That said I wish they had been a bit more intelligent and subtle about the GM message in this adaptation! Personally I would avoid the Book of Dave unless I needed something to wipe my arse or light a fire, but there are newer apocalypse novels that deserve dramatisation.

Re: The Day Of The Triffids episode 2 review
Posted By cordas2 1 January 3, 2010 03:30:49 PM

p.s. Although I would prefer to see some near future dystopia rather than apocalypse.

Re: The Day Of The Triffids episode 2 review
Posted By lesmond 1 January 6, 2010 08:30:04 AM

I'm with keith.perry totally on this one. It passed a couple of otherwise empty (from a TV point of view) evenings, but left an awful lot out. If you haven't read it, do, then read the rest of John Wyndham's books, because they're well worth it.

Re: The Day Of The Triffids episode 2 review
Posted By bobmackintosh 1 January 6, 2010 01:22:00 PM

The Chrysalids next please!
Post a Comment
 
The Day Of The Triffids Part Two

The Day Of The Triffids

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Broadband

Mobile Broadband

Compare over 100 mobile broadband & broadband deals online!

Mobile Phones

LG ArenaHTC Magic

Compare over 250 mobile phones &
52,000 deals!

Click Here