Den of Geek

V episode 3 review

Ron Hogan


In the penultimate episode of this year, V once more proves that it's one of the best shows of the season...

Published on Nov 18, 2009


3. A Bright New Day

There was a lot of stuff going on in tonight's episode of V. There are wheels within wheels, double-crosses and triple-crosses, and the long-awaited reveal of the presence of the Fifth Column (which feels like it needs initial capitalization due to being an awesome name of a resistance group in general, as well as a reference to the specific anti-fascist resistance group from the Spanish Civil War). However, before I get into that, I need to take a moment to praise the breakout star of V.

Morena Baccarin, as the V's supreme leader Anna, has just been the absolute best thing about the show thus far, and that's saying something because I'm a big fan of the show so far. She's knocked this role out of the park, and given that she's the most important character on the program, she's going to be what carries it or allows it to fail (well, the writers' use of Anna, anyway).

This was a very heavy Anna episode, and while she never says much, she says a ton with her expressions. The way she tightens her mouth or widens her eyes or softens her forehead just conveys the right amount of either her soothing facade or the cruel alien overlord we all know her to be, depending on the situation. This has been, by far, one of the better performances I've seen on television in some time.

After the delays of last week, the American government has submitted to diplomatic pressure and has issued visitor visas to the, err, Visitors, with Anna leading the way to get the very first surface pass.

Any big change like this is going to rile up the anti-V protesters, who have reached a fevered pitch outside the Manhattan Visitors area, clashing with police and even making a death threat towards Anna. This allows Erica, in her FBI agent capacity, to both get inside the Manhattan mothership and earn some good citizen points with Anna and the Visitors by busting up the assassination attempt.

It also allows Anna to really work the media. The one thing I like most about the show is that, as the Visitors get more experience in dealing with us and the media, they become better at manipulating the media. Last episode's Media 101 lesson from Chad Decker has really paid off for Anna and company, as they manage to turn both the assassination attempt and the anti-V side's best spokeswoman against them (Mary Faulkner, the widow of the pilot of the F-16 killed in the very beginning of episode 1.1 due to the V ship knocking his plane from the sky).

Of course, the assassination attempt was a set-up. There are wheels within wheels on V, and you can never quite tell just what is going to happen next. This episode featured not only one, but two double-crosses. Just when you think you've got a handle on who is what, the show takes another unexpected twist (but not in the dumbassed M. Night Shyamalan way).

It's unclear who is a Visitor and who is not. Even if you know someone is a visitor, you still can't really tell just who is on what side, aside from Ryan, Fr. Jack, and Erica. The Visitors, the human resistance, and now, the Fifth Column of anti-V Visitors are all entangled with one another.

Humans are in relationships with lizards. Lizards are turning against other Lizards. Humans are turning against some Lizards, and making alliances with other Lizards. The Visitors have sleepers in the FBI, the Fifth Column has agents in the Visitor motherships and the FBI, and for all we know, there are human resistance members in the Peace Ambassador program. Given how extensive and subtle the V surveillance has been, there's no telling just how far their tendrils reach.

Given that the show is about to go on hiatus until 2010 (and there might be changes during the time off), there has to be something big coming in the next episode to keep viewers waiting. It seems like we're building up to something pretty big next episode (at least, I hope we are). The various sects of resistance are coming together quite nicely, and the Visitor's plans are coming along nicely.

More importantly, the new V series finally has its signature graffiti in the form of the phrase, "John May Lives." It's a nice nod to the "Who is John Galt?" refrain from Atlas Shrugged, and the reveal near the end of the episode after Ryan escapes from the clutches of a Visitor attack squad was really visceral and quite well done. Every good movement needs a slogan, and I think the new Fifth Column has found theirs.

Read our review of the episode 2 here.

US correspondent Ron Hogan has become president of the Morena Baccarin Fan Club. We get navy blazers with white piping. Find more by Ron at his blog, Subtle Bluntness, and daily at Shaktronics and PopFi.

 

Tags

Users Comments

Re: V episode 3 review
Posted By Forecaster 1 November 18, 2009 01:14:45 PM

Nice review, a lot of twists going on, couple things...why dosen't Fr. Jack have a clue yet. He is leaving cell phone messages about the Vs. He knows the FBI is infiltrated. I hope he stops being naive. Also, the jig is up with erica's son - she now knows!. Its obvious no guy that geeky who hangs with a friend like that can get a girl that hot. She is a great FBI agent, she must be able to figure out she is a visitor.

Re: V episode 3 review
Posted By Naneek1 1 November 18, 2009 10:57:05 PM

Awesome third episode. But a few annoying things come to mind. Doesn't it bother anyone that the Visitors have patches on their jackets producing HD quality camera images and yet the sentry probes (like in ep. 1) can't muster up much more than a blotchy image? Of course, we're supposed to swallow that based on the inconvenience to the narrative that would be caused if those probes had been able to reproduce Erica and Jack's faces. But what about the inconvenience to logical minds? For a show that, as Mr. Hogan pointed out in his previous review, excels at making you scrutinize every aspect of the the show, this seems a little insulting to our intelligence. Whatever. Suspension of disbelief and all that. Predictions: 1) Next episode we find out why the Visitors don't want to damage the humans in a war: we are potential food. 2) Lisa will become more and more conflicted in her duping of Tyler, even though she's Anna's daughter. Look at her eyes at the very last shot of this episode. 3) Chad Decker's assistant, who's always around to praise his work in bringing about success for the Visitors, is a Visitor herself. Note how she's always steering him away from negative thoughts about his pawn-like role at the hands of Anna's control of info.

Re: V episode 3 review
Posted By Naneek1 1 November 18, 2009 11:01:47 PM

P.S. It strikes me that Mr. Hogan has joined the Peace Ambassador Program. Don't trust him!

Re: V episode 3 review
Posted By cordas 1 November 19, 2009 03:39:05 PM

I am not sure how deeply you can scrutinise the show....It has some pretty retarded moments not just the hd cameras in clothing, but leaving spybots with a dodgy old video camera with a resolution barely in double figures. There is also the issue of the turned 5th col guy breaking into Ryan's house to plant a business card in the hope that he finds it and comes visiting so he can turn him in... Why not just give his name and addy over and not risk getting burnt to a cinder. Regardless I am enjoying this show and am peeved that there is only 1 ep left before they take an X month break for some retarded reason.

Re: V episode 3 review
Posted By hockeystick 1 November 26, 2009 05:38:43 AM

My friens, I had to join this forum just to vent. You all seem like huge fans and I hate to be a buzz kill. But this show is borderline unwatchable. It is frustrating because it has such a great concept. And of course visually it is pretty captivating. But what lazy writing! Omigosh - - - such a ridiculous number of preposterous coincidences (e.g., Tyler seeks out a therapist, who turns out to be none other than Ryan's girlfriend - - - puh-lease). And so drearily predictable - - - almost every "twist" is telegraphed far in advance (again with Ryan's girlfriend, I knew she was going to be pregnant from almost the second her character was introduced - - - I involuntarily groaned with dismay when it was revealed to be the case). About the only thing in this series so far that I didn't see coming a mile away was Joshua the V doctor being part of the Fifth Column. And so much bewildering implausibility! One irritating scene out of many: When Erica finds out that Ryan is a V, and he tells her to get all her questions off her chest, wouldn't she ask him who the V's are, where they came from and why he rebelled? Instead she wants to now why the scientist got shot in the parking garage and whether there are other rebel V's. That's it. It was maddeningly idiotic that she'd just let that slide. It's a shame - - - I really wanted to like this show. But the writing is just too lame. I can suspend disbelief, but I can't overlook sloppy adolescent writing (apologies to adolescents everywhere). I think I'm done.

Re: V episode 3 review
Posted By etoh76 1 November 26, 2009 10:47:04 AM

Agree with hockeystick 100%, I had to vent about much the same stuff in the 4th episode comments section. I suspected Joshua was a V before the reveal (he's handsome, but not sinister handsome), but didn't anticipate how stupid he'd be.
Post a Comment
 
V: A Bright New Day

V: A Bright New Day

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Broadband

Mobile Broadband

Compare over 100 mobile broadband & broadband deals online!

Mobile Phones

LG ArenaHTC Magic

Compare over 250 mobile phones &
52,000 deals!