Amazon.co.uk Widgets
Den of Geek

V pilot episode review

Ron Hogan


Ron checks out the first episode of the new take on V - and it's one impressive opening...

Published on Nov 4, 2009

Wow. Just... wow. You know how some programs start off kind of slow and kind of ease you into the plot? Well, V doesn't do that. In fact, I can honestly say I haven't been this excited about a TV show, or this willing to sing its praises, since the premier of Deadwood (which I spent weeks annoying friends and family about). So, what's the set-up?

V starts with one of the most impressively ominous cold openings I've seen on TV in quite some time, and it just keeps getting more and more interesting. The Visitor ships descend on 29 major cities around the world, including New York and Los Angeles, in a scene similar to the appearance of the alien crafts in Independence Day. However, when the ID ships opened up with death lasers, the V ships turn into gigantic televisions, broadcasting the first address of V leader Anna (Morena Baccarin from Firefly and Serenity).

The message? "We are of peace. Always." People cheer. I mean, honestly, after the initial shock of the visitors landing and the first tentative steps to diplomacy, once they established they weren't here to start melting our faces off with acid spit and laying eggs in our chest, the offer of superior alien technology and universal health care sounds pretty damn good, especially since they can cure a number of diseases we humans currently can't. Combine that with Anna's smooth-talking interviews with TV newscaster Chad Decker (Scott Wolf), and it's no wonder that after three weeks people are lining up to visit the spectacular ships of the otherworldly Visitors.

This has the makings of some seriously good science-fiction television, but with enough other elements to keep non-sci-fi fans checking in. For example, there's some good relationship drama between FBI agent Erica Evans (Elizabeth Mitchell) and her son Tyler (Logan Huffman), who defies his mother's wishes to become one of the first Peace Ambassadors due to his crush on alien hottie Lisa (Laura Vandervoort). There's also some relationship rumblings between businessman Ryan Nichols (Morris Chestnut) and Valerie Holt (Lourdes Benedicto), which fulfills our drama quotient and sets up nicely for some other subplots coming up.

The majority of the opening episode is one guaranteed to win over the police procedural fans in the audience. Given that CSI and the like are the big shows on broadcast television, it's only natural that some of those elements are worked into V, as Agent Evans and her partner Agent Maddox (Alan Tudyk, also from Serenity and Dollhouse) are in hot pursuit of a renegade terrorist cell. Unlike most terrorist groups, which slowed down or stopped their activities in the face of the Visitors appearance, this one picked up activity, as if preparing for an attack on the US, or some other defenseless group.

The FBI springs into action, tracking the active terrorist cell to an abandoned warehouse, where they find a tortured and mangled body. From there, it's into a secret meeting where it is revealed that, perhaps, the aliens aren't all they seem to be. Or perhaps that Internet hoaxes will stand the test of time and always reappear, no matter what they might be related to.

The chase and the terror cell subplot takes up a lot of the episode, and it's really good television. The whole show is really good television, and it creates a whole lot of great questions about the relationship between the media and the people whom they cover, about the existence of aliens and how that might jibe with Catholic law and our current religions (carried by the character of Joel Gretsch's Father Jack Landry), and of course, about how, when something is too good to be true, it probably is.

There's a lot of bubbling politics that can be mined under the surface (the debates are already raging on the Internet not an hour after the show ended) for people on all sides of any issue, and that's a sign of good writing (and a good way to keep everyone watching and talking).

Scott Peters, who previously did The 4400 and The Outer Limits, among other things, has really taken on a challenge here and has really excelled in making the new V not just a show about aliens, but a show about humans dealing with the presence of other life in the universe. Add in some great special effects, a killer cast, and very crisp directing by TV vet Yves Simoneau, and you've got yourself a really good pilot episode.

The only problem with such a great pilot episode is that the other episodes have to stack up to the high expectations. The first show went through a lot in a pretty short time, but it set up a whole lot more. I'm very interested in seeing where this is going, and I can only hope the rest of the show stands up to the debut.

US correspondent Ron Hogan says, "Bring on the hottie alien reptiles!" Find more by Ron at his blog, Subtle Bluntness, and daily at Shaktronics and PopFi.

 

Tags

Users Comments

Re: V pilot episode review
Posted By neo727 1 November 4, 2009 12:42:52 PM

I was disappointed by the piolet. I thought the timeline jumped to quickly, what was it 3-4 weeks. They already know they are reptiles. I think there should of been some more build up to that. I hope they can at least put some suspense in the program for future episode or else it will Peter out like Invasion after one season. They should of focused on the good for the first few episodes with only a few small hints as to the undeying reasons they had come. To jump so far ahwead in the storyline was dumb.

Re: V pilot episode review
Posted By KafkasCat 1 November 4, 2009 02:30:07 PM

I think they jumped so far ahead so they could focus on peoples actual reactions rather than just their shock and awe. Everyone already knows they are reptiles so revealing it didn't bother me, if they had built to it I would have been more annoyed because I would have been waiting for them to reveal something we all know already. I'm kinda sad that Alan Tudyk wont be in it any more the guy is awesome.

Re: V pilot episode review
Posted By RobGordon23 1 November 4, 2009 04:14:30 PM

I always find that TV shows thrive on keeping the most obvious plot point a mystery, like Lost with everything. V, on the other hand, doesn't waste time in throwing down with its bombshells and I can honestly say I wasn't left annoyed waiting for the obvious reveal. Only problem is that it seems to want to focus on the resistance aspect which could cost money and if the rating don't play out to the ridiculously high standard of the network, we could see it asked pretty quick.

Re: V pilot episode review
Posted By RobGordon23 1 November 4, 2009 04:15:42 PM

*axed pretty quick. Minor typo

Re: V pilot episode review
Posted By vasces 1 November 4, 2009 06:37:28 PM

I remember the "reveal" from the original mini series back in the 80's. (That made me feel old). It was one of the best ever. She picks up the rodent and just wolfs it down. I was really looking forward to how they would do the reveal in the new series, hoping for some sort of homage to the original. Sadly, no such luck, just hit a guy in the head and mess up his makeup, huh? Other than that, I was pretty happy with the pilot.

Re: V pilot episode review
Posted By Forecaster 1 November 4, 2009 08:33:31 PM

Ummm - Alan Tudyk did not die. He was in the coming attractions for next week. I enjoyed the episode very much and excited about the series. I hope it sticks. I felt the same after Terminator - Sarah Chronicles and looked what happened to that. Lot of other sites have people nitpicking etc. to the original. But change and updates are good - why rehash the same story line? PS. Elizabeth Mitchell is excellent. Love her in lost and her too

Re: V pilot episode review
Posted By Forecaster 1 November 4, 2009 08:34:43 PM

* Lost and here too (although I would defintely love her too)

Re: V pilot episode review
Posted By etoh76 1 November 5, 2009 01:57:46 PM

Was a tad disappointed. I'm just old enough to remember the debut of the original series and how it took the world by storm. It was a real media event, and I was hoping for something on par. But in the first 35-40 minutes we were introduced to the same old characters we get in every other contemporary show - teenagers that act like twats, bland yet attractive soap actors, and the smug FBI (again with the FBI!). Why work this into a sci-fi show when everyone else is doing it? I didn't believe the communal applause everyone "spontaneously" gave after seeing Anna's introductory speech - in the sense that it's not the natural reaction following pandemonia in the streets caused by an aerial attack (unless Spiderman is fighting The Green Goblin over a bunch of New Yorkers). I also wasn't persuaded by the resistence movement, and would have liked to have seen some on screen evidence of why exactly the "V's" need to be resisted against in the first place, as in the original, instead of relying on the ravings of a conspiracy theorist with a few photographs. I mean, I dont exactly trust humans to be the goodies either. Which I think might be the underlying problem, as the premise of this show seems to be that Earth isn't messed up because of people - no, people are inherently good - it was the V's all along who were instigating terrorist plots and inciting racial and religious hatred. I just dont buy it. And dont get me started on that priest...

Re: V pilot episode review
Posted By cordas 1 November 5, 2009 03:03:14 PM

I felt the 1st episode was to rushed, I can understand why they rushed the reptile reveal... after all its V, 90+% of the audience are already going to know that so why string us along with a none surprise. I liked the idea that they have been here for years preparing, and I really hope that is something that is going to e properly explored! I understand the concerns etoh76 raises on this, but I think they would have to be retarded to go as far as that. I am just surprised they felt the need to shoe horn in Daniel joining the visitor corps, and the fact that their is a vistor 5th column into the 1st episode... It just wasn't needed

Re: V pilot episode review
Posted By cordas 1 November 5, 2009 03:03:42 PM

P.S. CAN WE PLEASE HAVE PARAGRAPH BREAKS BACK!!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: V pilot episode review
Posted By etoh76 1 November 5, 2009 03:51:17 PM

Ironically there is a current real world conspiracy theory where a group of people believe that the Earth is covertly manipulated by reptilian aliens (i.e. David Icke and the Illuminati) so this is interesting in the sense of the parallels that could be drawn there (in that they've been here all along setting the scene for invasion).I'm not making this up either.

Re: V pilot episode review
Posted By Illuminatus 1 November 12, 2009 07:00:28 AM

Good pilot episode, enjoyed it very much. I agree it did move very fast, is this the speed of TV show we have become used to, in order to keep our attention? For conspiracy fans such as myself did anyone notice the masonic tie-in's? The black and white checkered floor in the TV studio, symbolizing the fight between good and evil, ying/yang etc. Also a nice 1st degree masonic handshake when Daniel joins the visitor corps, i hope the writers keep throwing these tid-bits in!
Post a Comment
 
V pilot

V

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Broadband

Mobile Broadband

Compare over 100 mobile broadband & broadband deals online!

Mobile Phones

LG ArenaHTC Magic

Compare over 250 mobile phones &
52,000 deals!