Den of Geek

Lost season 5 episode 4 review

James Hunt


A weak entry, but even ticking over, Lost beats many other shows revving up...

Published on Feb 9, 2009

After last week’s Jackless episode, it was virtually a given that this one was going to feature the two most gurning, tedious members of the Oceanic Six heavily, and indeed it did as Kate and Jack took centre stage in a bid to sort out the problem of who, exactly, is trying to take Aaron away from Kate.

It’s all about as dull as Lost ever gets (though mercifully, we’re still nowhere near the infamously terrible tattoo-rape episode) and thankfully, a lot of much more interesting stuff happens on the island as well. The sickness afflicting some characters seems to strike those who have been on the island longest first, so seeing Miles get ill second adds a particularly interesting twist, since he doesn’t think he’s been there before. Between that, his ethnicity, and his oft-used magical powers, the theory that he is actually the child of Chang/Halliwax/Candle (the guy who does the ultra-awesome 'induction films') seen at the start of episode one of this fifth series, has actually gained substantial weight.

As ever, the time-shifting is what makes the episode worth watching – indeed, the off-island shenanigans designed to get the Oceanic Six back together are particularly obvious, and it wouldn’t surprise me at all to find that the vengeful Sun, seemingly tasked by Widmore to attack Ben, was actually hired by Ben himself to ensure she got to the docks at the same time as the rest of them.

Of course, Sun needn’t be too concerned about vengeance, because Jin isn’t actually dead anyway. His return from the 'dead' was completely predictable, and for that reason it’s good that we got to see it relatively early on in the season. Everyone knows that on genre TV, death doesn’t mean a thing unless you see a corpse, and even then you can’t be sure. The consequences of having Jin back have yet to become clear, though it is quite hilarious that after spending months learning English, he’s now found himself amongst a group of French-speakers.

Speaking of which - one problem with Lost’s new penchant for connecting the dots is that we, as viewers, have been well-trained to do it ourselves. This means that when, after a good five minutes of screen-time, the woman in the French boat crew dramatically reveals that “my name is Danielle” – as in Danielle Rousseau – we’re already quite far along with that assumption. It’s not the first time that’s happened this series, and it can really suck the fun out of what should be cliffhanger moments.

Although this may be the poorest episode of the series, there’s still enough happening to keep it over. While the introduction of yet another group of mysterious, gun-toting island arivees makes me roll my eyes with the painful inevitability of it all, this is offset by the way we get to see a key moment of Lost’s mythos realised in the arrival (in the past) of Rousseau’s sciences team. Call me obvious, but I’m now hoping that one day we get to see the Black Rock getting beached inland by a storm, and the inevitable Losties Vs. Pirates fight that entails. Don’t pretend I’m alone in wanting to see it.

Check out a review of episode 3 here.

Den Of Geek List of Lost

 

Users Comments

Re: Lost season 5 episode 4 review
Posted By capt_1ntens0 1 February 9, 2009 01:53:53 PM

A fair summation of the episode. Poorest this season (OK we're only 4 in but hey), but it was no Eggtown either. I must admit, I wasn't expecting Jin back- Lost has been pretty good at killing off key characters and leaving them dead (unless in Jacob/smokie form). I just want to know how he managed in the split seconds he had to not only clear the blast but get so close to the island that he managed to time travel with everyone else whilst the helicopter was left behind? Maybe he got blown a long way by the explosion, if so I hope he didn't fly over a shark on the way...

Re: Lost season 5 episode 4 review
Posted By bobsuncorp 1 February 9, 2009 05:06:39 PM

The thing I am most excited about is finding out how the mysteries on the island were put there by the various inhabitants: We have seen the hatches being built, we have seen the beginnings of the barracks. We have not yet seen the huge 3 toed foot being constructed, and we don't know yet who the "Adam and Eve" skeletons are (they could be 2 of our main characters). And of course we haven't seen who (or what) built the ice cave structures, and who the hell is Richard Alpert?!

Re: Lost season 5 episode 4 review
Posted By varoh 1 February 9, 2009 06:23:42 PM

Waaa. I inexplicably hate Jack due to the fact that I think the writers are trying to make him cool but failing and in no way due to the fact that he is written as a deeply conflicted and troubled person who as the most relatable character on the show is used to illustrate how we as average people would, for the most part, react to all the trials and traumas he has been through. Basicallt enough with the Jack bashing. Sawyer's who we'd wish we'd be but Jack is who we are.

Re: Lost season 5 episode 4 review
Posted By warl0ck 1 February 10, 2009 01:11:50 AM

A fine analysis, varoh, and a well written one, too. However, I have NO desire to be Sawyer. ;)

Re: Lost season 5 episode 4 review
Posted By LizLemon 1 February 10, 2009 10:17:37 AM

From the beginning, I always felt Jack had the most to lose of almost all the main stranded islanders. I completely agree that he's a study of the challenge of keeping sight and control of principles and convictions under strenuous circumstances. Call me crazy, but I've always preferred the good guy over the bad boy.

Re: Lost season 5 episode 4 review
Posted By Codgin 1 February 10, 2009 11:47:52 AM

I wouldn't say the poorest episode, despite its laughs Id say the Lie earns that title, the cliffhanger made this episode worth it, I do however feel this episode was one of those build up episodes that serve no other purpose than to build up to something more interesting in the next episode.

Re: Lost season 5 episode 4 review
Posted By Codgin 1 February 10, 2009 11:50:15 AM

Oh and Losties Vs Pirates yes your not alone, I'm crying out for this as well lol

Re: Lost season 5 episode 4 review
Posted By warl0ck 1 February 12, 2009 12:45:50 AM

For whatever reasons, audiences always seem to be more "forgiving" of dark characters who show glimpses of light (a la Sawyer) than they are heroic characters who show flashes of darkness (a la Jack). The tables have really turned from a time when being "bad" was rebellious to a time when being "good" is rebellious. I think the character of Jack is a very human, sympathetic and yes, quite admirable character (BECAUSE of his imperfection, not in spite of it) who is played superbly by Matthew Fox. If they were all "Sawyers" there'd be nothing to buck up against philsophically, and the show would be much poorer for it.

Re: Lost season 5 episode 4 review
Posted By stuxmusic 1 February 15, 2009 02:57:10 PM

If you weren't a big fan of episode 4, episode 5 won't make you smile either. It's downhill from ep4. But with 316 and L&D of JB coming next, I figure it's literally the calm before the storm.

Re: Lost season 5 episode 4 review
Posted By charley19 1 February 19, 2009 10:30:43 PM

I don't think the cliffhangers are getting 'ruined'. The writers know exactly what they're doing; when they want our jaws to drop, they do (i.e., the first flash forward). Instead of jumping from one jaw-dropping event to the next, which would be contrived and annoying, they tease out the implications of new developments over time, as they're doing with the time-travel. So we get to figure things out sometimes, as we all did when Sawyer asked if anyone spoke french. Sometimes we get to get shocked, sometimes we get to piece bits together. Don't pretend you don't love both. Nice review, though. And agreed, it's not one of the strongest episodes.
Post a Comment
 
Lost

Lost

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Broadband

Mobile Broadband

Compare over 100 mobile broadband & broadband deals online!

Mobile Phones

LG ArenaHTC Magic

Compare over 250 mobile phones &
52,000 deals!