View Archive |
Home
| Movies
WALL-E review
Ron Hogan
Ron likes the cute robot but isn't so sure about the environmental credentials of Pixar's latest blockbuster...
BE WARNED - POSSIBLE SPOILERS...
WALL-E, like most of Pixar’s fare, is a movie with a message. Well, actually, the movie has several messages, and it relentlessly beats the viewer’s skull in with the blunt hammer of poorly-done social criticism and lazy writing until even the average house plant can understand what the writers are trying to convey. Since the movie is about a trash-cleaning robot on an abandoned, polluted Earth, obviously one of the messages is that we need to start recycling and stop polluting. I got that part from the trailers; as that message was pounded into me again and again, I was compelled with the urge to throw trash out of my windows on the drive home. May as well keep the robots busy, after all.
Disney is nothing but hypocritical for telling me I need to recycle more and stop using so much energy while using more energy in one day than I could use in my entire life. Even if I tried, I couldn’t use as much electricity as Disney does. I know Westerners create a lot of garbage, but how much garbage does Disney create? How much garbage will be created by cheap plastic WALL-E toys and tie-ins that are destined to get thrown away once the cheap Chinese plastic they’re made of breaks? Hell, how much electricity was used to run the server farms and design computers needed to put WALL-E together?
Do you know what else WALL-E says is evil? Wal-Mart, Tesco, and all the big-box retailers (that just so happen to sell all the Disney/Pixar branded toys, games, DVDs, VHS tapes, plush toys, coloring books, and enema kits). The company that creates all the trash is a generic Big Box company called Buy’n’Large, helmed by CEO Shelby Forthright (Fred Willard, in the first live-action scenes ever included in a Pixar movie). Their gigantic, wasteful stores, with dozens of gas pumps, only encourage the smog that chokes the air in WALL-E’s future. Their encouragement of consumerism creates the walls of trash that clutter the planet. Sure, they also made the space ships that allowed humanity to survive, and they created the WALL-E robots that are cleaning up the earth, but that doesn’t mean they’re not still evil! They create junk food and they turn people into sheeple! They’re sucking up all the planet’s resources and selling it back to you at low low prices!
Oh, I forgot, people are also evil. Specifically, big fat lazy people who suck down junk food, fly around on hover couches all day, and spend all their time on future versions of cell phones (even if their equally fat friend is hovering beside them). That’s right, lardass, Pixar wants you to put down your box of Finding Nemo Swedish fish and your Mickey Mouse ice cream bars and get some exercise! Stop staring at video screens all damn day and take a look at the world around you!
Are you getting the point yet? That you should actually look at things when you’re not watching your 1800 Disney/Pixar DVDs? That you should be active outside of the cubicle and get off the couch once in awhile so you don’t become a slave to helpful future robots? If you’re not, WALL-E will gladly keep ramming the point home until it knifes through the 18 layers of blubber growing on your ponderous torso and impales your cholesterol-encrusted heart with the barb of life-changing awakenings.
If you can get past the middle portion of the film, which goes well out of its way to cram its messages into your popcorn cavern, the movie itself is actually very sweet.
The first third of the film, which showcases the incredibly lonely WALL-E’s (voiced by Ben Burtt, who does most of the robots in the movie) daily routine of gathering trash into his belly, compacting it into squares, and stacking the squares into skyscrapers, is gorgeous to look upon. The ruined earth is picture perfect, and the dingy but expressive little robot is the sort of character who audiences will instantly fall in love with. He passes the time collecting interesting bits of junk, watching the old musical Hello Dolly!, and hanging out with a cockroach. It’s nearly completely silent, with no actual dialogue. The only communication is robot noises and, of course, WALL-E’s classically expressive Disney bug-eyes.
He’s the last of his kind, a fleet of robots sent to clean up the earth after humanity has messed it all up with our consumer waste and SUVs. Humanity has abandoned the Blue Marble, and it’s up to WALL-E to clean up after us while collecting a mishmash of 80’s technology to play with in his down time (possibly an homage to WALL-E’s resemblance to Johnny Five from Short Circuit). Day in and day out, he picks up his cooler, rolls off to the trash piles, and rolls home again, with no company save our long-discarded media and his indestructible roach buddy.
That is, of course, until the sleek and (I guess) robo-sexy EVE (Elissa Knight) shows up in a blast of fire and the spectacular landing of a rocket. EVE is on a mission, sent down from the spaceship habitat Axiom. She’s searching earth for any sign of plant life. WALL-E is searching for a friend (or possibly girlfriend, hubba hubba). Sparks fly, but it takes awhile for the courtship to actually work. However, things go sour when EVE finds what she’s looking for and gets recalled back to the Axiom. WALL-E, in true romantic comedy fashion, refuses to let a little thing like space stop him, and journeys to the Axiom to follow his beloved EVE.
The sweetest (and best) parts of the film were all centered on WALL-E and EVE. WALL-E’s cuddliness always comes through, no matter who he’s interacting with. He wins over two of the tubby citizens of the Axiom, John (John Ratzenberger) and Mary (Kathy Najimy), who change their slovenly ways thanks to the power of WALL-E. He changes the robots he comes in contact with, from MO the cleaning robot to even the giant compactor robots in the ship’s garbage chutes. He even wins the heart of the ship’s Captain (Jeff Garlin), and eventually awakens the entire human portion of the ship while battling the evil autopilot Otto, voiced by the MacinTalk program (one of a TON of Apple references in the movie) and inspired by HAL 9000.
Can you tell Pixar shares a corporate father with Apple yet? Director/Writer Adam Stanton may as well have had Steve Jobs show up and lecture me about how he saved the earth from Microsoft and Wal-Mart.
WALL-E is one special robot. Not only did he manage to change the entire world, he also made me forget how distasteful and cloying the middle section of the film was after the gorgeous, emotionally poignant beginning. It had lots of Chaplinesque slapstick, some sweetly funny moments between WALL-E and EVE, and a garbage dumpster full of cuteness to spare, but that’s not enough for me to rate the film as stellar. If Stanton had kept the love story center-stage, or made the preachy middle a little less ham-fisted, then we’d have a different ending to this review.
Wal-Mart is bad! Pollution is bad! Consumerism is bad! But Ron Hogan is good! Find more by Ron at his blog, Subtle Bluntness, and daily at Shaktronics and PopFi.
The Screen Robots Ready Reckoner
Check out WALL-E's predecessors in arguably the most exhaustive rundown of screen robots on the web.
This review was posted for many hours in an incomplete form. We're not sure what happened, but our apologies to Ron for giving the mistaken impression that he'd made incomplete commentary on WALL-E - Den Of Geek
User's Comments
Re: WALL-E reviewThanks for the anti-Disney polemic... Any chance of an actual movie review? | |
Re: WALL-E reviewI've got one coming, Half-way through it already... Ocean Fracture Sean? Random, tis Carl! Anywho, can this have 'Spoiler' put at the top please because it totally is full of them. | |
Re: WALL-E reviewYes indeed Carl - frequent viewer, infrequent commentor. | |
Re: WALL-E reviewIf you want to go further down this road, I already pointed out an article in one of my EIFF reports - check it out.
| |
WTF???Either everyone else who's seen this film is drinking the proverbial Kool-Aid or Mr Hogan got out of the wrong side of his coffin yesterday.
Everyone else seems to have seen joy, wonder and brilliant moviemaking in this latest Pixar film. All he sees is the opportunity to mouth off like Jeremy Clarkson and Jon Gaunt's unwanted love child.
Review precis:
"If you can get past the front, middle, and penultimate sentence of this cab driver's diatribe, the last sentence itself actually passes comment on the quality of the film" | |
Re: WALL-E reviewIn my defense, for some reason only half my review was actually posted. I'm not sure why. Will ask about and see if I can get the other pages of the review put up. | |
Re: WALL-E reviewPlease hold off on accusing me of being a vampire or a cabbie until after the rest of the review goes up. For some reason, only half of my extensive review of the film was published. | |
Re: WALL-E reviewAlso, I don't read CHUD or AICN, for what that's worth. If they had cut the message aspect in about half, or made it less blatant and more subtle, I would've loved the film too. That's the only thing that stopped me from really enjoying it, because after the initial opening jabs at Wal-Mart (which were amusing), it just took away from the film's momentum and bogged it down. | |
Re: WALL-E reviewWell, it's a Pixar film. What do you expect? This is the sort of movie they do. You've got your moment where you giggle, the moments where you go awwww, and your actiony moments. And for the record, it's actually kind of creepy when an entire audience goes awwww at once. | |
Re: WALL-E reviewNow that the whole review is up, feel free to comment again if you still have problems with it. Or more importantly, if you don't. | |
Re: WALL-E reviewThing is, the humans are portrayed sympathetically. They're dumb, yes, but the instant they're shaken out of their stupor they embrace the world outside their pods. They love it. There really AREN'T any evil characters in this movie- the character you would think is the villain is just following a really bad directive. | |
Re: WALL-E reviewYou´re missing too much there. First, this is a Pixar movie, part of the agreement was that Disney was gonna stay out creatively, so Pixar is free to bash even against Disney type giants and their toys. Second, they are talking about excesses, not about those things being necessarily evil. Third, one of the things I loved most about the movie, which is different to other typical alarmist preachy movies, is precisely the fact that humans end up being true well intentioned people. Humans create a world in a spaceship that in the end became dominated by their robots as they comfortably and contentedly lived on, but once they start seeing new things, Pixar is sure to show how the human creativity and determination are still more powerful than the entrapment of vice. In the end, the captain saved the day while the whole story with the robots, who were in some way living out what the humans were forgettting, went on in the forefront. At first, I reacted against the decision of making them all fat and seemingly stupid, but by the end I more than accepted it given all this. I simply loved how they exalted human creativity and will power and not leave it all to the robots who had a story of their own. |
Post a comment
WALL-E: a machine with a (possibly overbearing) message...
Related Articles
- 13 utterly bonkers action movies
- Bluray drive in works for 360
- Daredevil going dark. Er. Darker.
- Shyamalan on The Happening
- The Crazies are coming again
- Guillermo del Toro talks The Hobbit
- The World Won't Listen: Pulp Fiction
- The Dark Knight sequel: David Goyer cuts through Batman rumours
- Pirates of the Caribbean 4: Tim Burton to direct?

