Amazon.co.uk Widgets
Den of Geek

Top 10 movie re-edits

Martin Anderson


Here are the films that benefited from a loving second-look in the editing suite...

Published on Sep 22, 2009

Greedo, go and stand at the back...

10: Leon International Cut

Running 23 minutes longer than the general theatrical release of Leon, most of the extra footage in this version is concentrated around the relationship between Jean Reno and Natalie Portman, greatly developing our understanding of the bond between the two. We also get some insight into the romantic misadventure that turned Leon into a hired killer. This is basically more of an already-great film, adding subtractable but rewarding depth to the characters.

9: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly

The 2004 re-mastered and re-edited special edition of Sergio Leone's spaghetti classic is not without its flaws - notably that the voices of old Clint Eastwood's and old Eli Wallach were too altered by the time they were asked to dub the soundless sections of TGTBATU that were restored in the film. Ironically the voice-actor standing in for the late Lee Van Cleef provides the best looping coverage of them all. But The film contains some very welcome 'new' scenes, including Tuco conspiring with his old bandit friends in a cave, and the amusing 'six bullets' sequence. The 'torture in the desert' scene is notably extended too, as Tuco literally makes a meal of his opportunity to take revenge on 'Blondie'.

8: Daredevil director's cut

Mark Steven Johnson's little-appreciated 2003 take on Marvel's blind superhero cut no great dash at the box-office or with critics, but the director's cut proved how harshly the original edit had been treated by producers and marketers. Daredevil V2.0 is a tighter, darker and far more engaging take on Matt Murdoch and his alter-ego. The re-edit features several subplots and telling scenes absent from the theatrical release, such as our hero pondering his numerous scars after dealing with a rapist, and Murdoch's defence of a Hell's Kitchen denizen falsely accused of murder. We get in the re-edit some sense of what Daredevil/Murdoch is fighting for, and what it costs him.

7: Superman II - The Richard Donner edition

Director Richard Donner laments in the extras on Superman that his reward for delivering Warner Brothers a huge blockbuster in Winter of 1978 was to get fired and replaced by Richard Lester, who nominally helmed Superman II and the rather lighter Superman III a couple of years later. Truth is that producers the Salkind Brothers, ever fond of dividing up a huge movie production into two films (as they had done with the Musketeers movies) had envisaged Superman and Superman II as rolling output. Soaring costs and overruns on principal photography and special effects on the first film meant that further funds for Superman II would have to await the outcome of the first film at the box office. Therefore great swathes of Superman II were already in the can by the time Donner himself was canned in favour of Salkind Bros. favourite Lester, and it was a pleasure to see the director's original vision for the sequel, even if it had to employ footage from a screen test between Christopher Reeve and Margot Kidder, in a clever scene that was ultimately replaced by the more action-oriented 'Niagara falls' sequence. The sequence where Superman receives some advice from the ghostly Jor-El, mainly in regards to not letting Earth-people abuse him as a resource, is also a fascinating restoration.

6: Aliens Director's Cut

The theatrical, VHS and Laserdisc edition of James Cameron's much-lauded sequel restored several segments which were excised to keep the popcorn flowing and the runtime low. None of them are really essential and one or two aren't necessarily wise, but there's nothing in the special edition that makes the film worse, and for those of us who had worn our VHS copies thin, it was a thrilling reinvigoration of an old favourite. Scenes restored included Ripley's dealing with the death of her daughter and an extended bit of business with the setting up of automatic machine-guns prior to the siege of the control room. The former served as perhaps-unnecessary set-up for Ripley's bond with Newt, the latter as an over-the-top tech/firepower wank for the boys (though watching quite that many aliens die automatically did thin down their menace for a little while). The most important addition was the restitution of the colony-scenes on LV421 leading up to the alien infestation, wherein we see Newt as a normal young girl and the colony in good order. Here we also get a very good look at the restored Giger alien spaceship, in some very impressive Skotak Bros. VFX work. There are a few other tweaks here and there, but this is basically a 'more Aliens per pound' deal - and seeing as Aliens is great, that's a pretty good deal.

5: Apocalypse Now Redux

There's some controversy as to the merits of restoring the French-colonialism scenes to the 2001 cinematic (and subsequent DVD) re-release of Francis Ford Coppola's anti-war hymnal. Though the technical aspects of this section which bothered the director so much were cleaned up digitally, some of the acting is below-par for the movie, some of the dialogue incomprehensible and all of Carmine Coppola's (FFC sr.) score for the segment an absolutely abysmal synth/organ dirge. But the restored segment has some wonderful moments, such as the ghostly appearance of the colonials at the beginning. Elsewhere the restitution of the 'Playboy bunny' scenes now seem, for me, irremovable from Apocalypse Now, along with the counterpoint of humour when Willard (Martin Sheen) steals the surfboard of gung-ho Col. Kilgore (Robert Duvall), soon followed by an even more amusing section where the colonel is scouring Vietnam for the offenders who stole his beloved board. Being able to laugh with these characters bonds them both to each other and to us, and lends both weight and sadness to subsequent events.

4: Star Trek: The Motion Picture Director's Cut

It's hard to believe that Robert Wise's 2004 re-edit of the 1979 blockbuster actually runs longer than the original, because it is almost infinitely more watchable. With a distance of years, Wise was able to bin the inordinate amount of expensive 'entering V'Ger' footage turned out by John Dykstra and Douglas Trumbull as superfluous to the telling of a tale about actual people. Ironically, the movie's tag-line 'The human adventure is just beginning' is still more applicable to Nick Meyer's superb 1982 sequel The Wrath Of Khan than this first movie, but if - like me - you were getting drowsy through the original release edit of TMP, give V2.0 a chance - it is an infinitely more watchable movie, with excess effects excised and large chunks of character-building and plot-driven scenes restored or enhanced. This version also provides a complete view of the unshielded V'Ger approaching Earth and an extended scene of V'Ger menacing 'the creator' by trying to remove its 'carbon-unit infestation'.

3: Blade Runner - The Director's Cut

It's disputed whether or not Harrison Ford deliberately gave a poor performance on the tacked-on Chandler-esque voice-over that the producers forced on Ridley Scott's cult classic shortly before release; Ford himself disputes it, admitting that he disliked the idea, but that once obliged to take part, he gave it as good a shot as such a lame notion - and script - could merit. Also excised in Scott's 1990 re-release were the out-takes from The Shining and the entire 'happy ending' scenario that the execs believed - unwisely - would help the movie at the box-office. The restoration of the 'unicorn' dream-sequence convinced many that Harrison Ford's Deckard was intended to himself be a replicant within the narrative, though to this day Ford and Scott hold different opinions on the matter. The superb DVD and Blu-ray special edition of 2008 cleaned up some of the production glitches, including the digital removal of the suspending wires on several prop-'spinners', but ultimately the 1990 re-edit gave most Blade Runner fans the version they prefer.

2: Alien 3 Special Edition

The justly-revered Alien quadrilogy box-set sets many things right regarding the film that David Fincher will neither touch, re-touch nor talk about. The special edition of this third entry in the Alien franchise, though not worked on at all by Fincher, follows the director's original work-print and intentions and actually begins to make sense of the movie's baffling fatalism. In the original script, the Dog-Alien was trapped in a nuclear storage bunker for a fair chunk of the middle of the film, until producers Giler and Hill decided that it degraded this classically scary creature to entrap it. Once that element was removed from Alien 3, a huge section of the film didn't make sense - why was everyone standing round pondering their navels when they were about to be eaten alive by the most feral and savage example of a race pretty well known for being feral and savage?

One of the welcome off-shoots of restoring this strand was the restitution of Paul McGann's performance as the religious maniac who identifies with the new guest on 'Fury' and sets it free, hoping to be led like a disciple (rather than just torn to pieces, which is what he gets). Additionally there is an extended sequence showing Dr. Charles Dance recovering Sigourney Weaver from the crash wreckage on the blasted surface of the planet. And there's a fair bit less running round corridors screaming.

Seriously, if you wrote off Alien 3 without seeing this version, you've literally only got half the story.

1: The Godfather saga

I'm referring here to the 1980s chronological TV-edit (later released to VHS but never to DVD) of Francis Ford Coppola's tale of a mobster family, which not only began with the Robert De Niro entry from Godfather Part II (1974) but included much previously-discarded footage and scenes from the two movies. This is the only way to appreciate the broad scope of the gangster epic, and it's only slightly ruined by the fact that both the Laserdisc chronological Godfather/II edit (1990) and the 1970s network TV chronological release both contain completely different excised scenes.

Time, then, for that definitive, utterly completist Godfather/II re-edit, Francis. This time please leave nothing out. Except Godfather Part III.

Click here for a list of ALL the lists at Den Of Geek...

 

Tags

Users Comments

Re: Top 10 movie re-edits
Posted By cordas 1 September 23, 2009 07:51:43 AM

You missed probably the best cut from the list... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=udcw3PJ3gQM&eurl=http%3A%2F%2f The only watchable cut of Superman3.

Re: Top 10 movie re-edits
Posted By TheDekline 1 September 23, 2009 08:45:21 AM

Ha ha Cordas, that's an excellent find! Fully agree with this list - Daredevil directors cut and Alien 3 were both significantly better films (because as mentioned with the replaced footage they actually made sense!) Will have to check out the ST:The Slow Motion Picure re-edit, haven't watched that in AGES. I don't know if The Lord Of The Rings extended editions count in this instance do they? Definately a more satifying watch, even if it does bump the total run time up a couple of hours! :-P

Re: Top 10 movie re-edits
Posted By Nocturne 1 September 23, 2009 08:59:25 AM

No Terminator 2 extended cut then ?

Re: Top 10 movie re-edits
Posted By TheDekline 1 September 23, 2009 09:54:58 AM

Damn, also forgot the Alien Special Edition/Directors Cut - really like the Ridley Scott re-edit, even if it is a bit shorter, the sequences added just after Kane is brought back aboard etc are really good!

Re: Top 10 movie re-edits
Posted By ERG1008 1 September 23, 2009 11:37:04 AM

Glad to see Alien 3 there. It is a much, much better film with the re-edit.

Re: Top 10 movie re-edits
Posted By capt_1ntens0 1 September 23, 2009 12:31:09 PM

Agree about Alien 3- remember reading the book adaptation before seeing it at the cinema and just thinking "huh?" when the religious zealot storyline disappeared along with Paul McGann for no explained reason. I've also heard very good things about Kingdom of Heaven Director's Cut, which Empire said is one of the finest extended edits they've ever seen. Not see it though but definitely want to. Having never watched Blade Runner all the way through (original bored me to sleep), I'm willing to give an extended version a try but don't even know where to start, there's about 10 versions now isn't there?

Re: Top 10 movie re-edits
Posted By blueoyster101 1 September 23, 2009 01:45:53 PM

Definitely check out Kingdom of Heaven Director's Cut, it's infinitely superior to the theatrical release. As are all the LOTR extended versions. I'd also recommend Troy - these all benefit from the maxim, take your time to tell your story!

Re: Top 10 movie re-edits
Posted By jonnyellis 1 September 23, 2009 03:23:06 PM

I would agree with blueoyster that Kingdom of Heaven definitely deserves a place in the list. I think the best re-edits of films that are out there are done by the fans. For example ADYWAN's much loved edit of 'Star Wars a New Hope' is to me the definitive edition of that film.See: http://bsmbow.blogspot.com/2008/03/star-wars-revisited-dvd-review.html Also the famous fan-edits of the Star Wars prequels are a text book lesson in how the art of editing can make even a steaming turd into a venus di milo. I strongly recommend getting hold of the most well known versions 'the phantom edit','attack of the phantom' and the Spence edit of 'revenge of the sith'. Whats more they also have a brilliant commentary from the editor. Here's a quick review: http://darthmojo.wordpress.com/2008/05/26/attackofthephantom/ For more fan edits see: http://fanedit.org/

Re: Top 10 movie re-edits
Posted By cbrigden 1 September 23, 2009 03:37:09 PM

I think most of the "director's cuts" are usually extraneous, with a few exceptions (notably BLADE RUNNER, ALIEN 3 and SUPERMAN II). ALIENS' extended version loses the tension and suspense, and the Newt as extension of Ripley's dead daughter is given too much exposure, especially with Cameron's clumsy writing, where the theatrical version works it nicely, although THE ABYSS is an essential Cameron DC. On the other hand, I'm not sure why STAR WARS needs editing at all. As much as George Lucas denies it, the definitive version of that film was released on May 25th, 1977. However there have been some very good fan edits of films that needed them (although, as I stated in my DVD review for this site, Star Trek TMP is - for me - certainly not an improvement.) It's just a shame the once fabled moniker of "Director's Cut" is now just a marketing tool.

Re: Top 10 movie re-edits
Posted By El_Luther 1 September 23, 2009 04:46:32 PM

I hate to be this guy but the planet in Aliens is LV-426.

Re: Top 10 movie re-edits
Posted By GoldbergV 1 September 23, 2009 06:57:16 PM

Southland Tales surely? The original cut (which for some reason, is the one shown on Sky) is absolutely awful, meandering and unfocused to the point of making almost no sense at all. The redited version, as per the DVD release, is much better, and actually comes off as watchable. Of course its still too long, unfocused and self-indulgent, but this time in a (kind of) good way.

Re: Top 10 movie re-edits
Posted By hideous 1 September 23, 2009 11:21:59 PM

Poor poor Ridley. I would add Legend to the list. Feels like they cut half the movie out for the american release. Very good list. And some cool things I didn't know. I shall definitely give the 3rd alien another whirl.

Re: Top 10 movie re-edits
Posted By ta_scott 1 September 23, 2009 11:52:11 PM

Like Bladerunner, Kingdom of Heaven Director's Cut was far far better than it's confusing theatrical release. Just goes to show that no studio (I'm looking at you 20th Century Fox!) can cut Ridley Scott films and expect them to work!

Re: Top 10 movie re-edits
Posted By kivel 1 September 24, 2009 05:28:22 AM

"All of These Movies on one Site" smacks of cell phone scam. If not I truly apologize, and if the site has DOG blessing, I may just use it, but if it smells like New Orleans after Marti Gras, the five second rule still don’t apply. How I visit DEN OF GEEK daily because such nonsense is not tolerated. OKAY that’s a lie I visit because up-to-date information on new projects as well as the look backs at gone but never forgotten and The Top Ten Lists. But discounting those reasons and Doctor Who coverage that no one else carries and . . . Okay, I love the Den, but please do me a favor and ban the "Watch All These Movies at One Site" purveyor to Hell of Geek

Re: Top 10 movie re-edits
Posted By theshadowalker 1 September 24, 2009 05:35:53 AM

I was just watching the "Wolverine" DVD and was aggravated to learn that the absolutely idiotic "adamantium bullet" subplot was, apparently, part of a series of reshoots that the director didn't sound entirely pleased with (and that the original explanation for Wolvie's erratic memory made a lot more sense...intellectually, and emotionally). Director's Cut, anyone? And just about the only Director's Cut that, IMO, wasn't an improvement on the original was that of "Bad Santa"...which turned a really dark comedy into a really depressing drama. Now, if I could just get a new cut of "Interview With the Vampire" that removes that stupid bit with the poodles and reinserts the key scene with Louis in the confessional, I'll be very happy...

Re: Top 10 movie re-edits
Posted By theshadowalker 1 September 24, 2009 05:40:21 AM

...and just after I'd written my comments, above, I realized that I'd temporarily forgotten about Lucas' hopelessly inept Director's Cuts (the dreaded "Special Editions"). Now, if only I could figure out how to re-forget them, I'd be very, very happy.

Re: Top 10 movie re-edits
Posted By mugwump 1 September 24, 2009 06:45:22 AM

I always thought the added scene with Newt and her family earlier on in Aliens DC as super-corny. Director's Cut usually suck, IMO, as all they do is tack-on the wanky stuff the producers have forced them to cut out in the edit.

Re: Top 10 movie re-edits
Posted By JJ_Lamour 1 September 24, 2009 10:13:07 AM

The DC of Highlander 2 was a vast improvement.

Re: Top 10 movie re-edits
Posted By MarvMarble 1 September 24, 2009 04:32:47 PM

"Having never watched Blade Runner all the way through (original bored me to sleep), I'm willing to give an extended version a try but don't even know where to start, there's about 10 versions now isn't there?" It's not really an 'extended cut' but I'd go for The Final Cut. It's pretty similar to the Director's Cut mentioned in the article but with a bit of CGI clean up. (Used in a subtle way I'd hasten to add. Don't worry, no dinosaurs lumbering in the background.) I understand why Director's cut was included in the list instead though. That was when the changes were truly made for the better. (Not that the theatrical cuts are bad.) You can't really go wrong if you go for the Director's Cut or Final Cut, but if you had to chose, I'd plump for the latter.

Re: Top 10 movie re-edits
Posted By MarvMarble 1 September 24, 2009 04:36:26 PM

"after I'd written my comments, above, I realized that I'd temporarily forgotten about Lucas' hopelessly inept Director's Cuts (the dreaded "Special Editions")." With the exception of the amount of dinosaurs included in A New Hope, I think they genuinely did enhance the look of the films, not that the original look was bad. The added affects in the Bespin sequence of The Empire Strikes Back certainly looked good.

Re: Top 10 movie re-edits
Posted By etoh76 1 September 24, 2009 08:42:57 PM

When I found out there was going to be a 'Final Cut' of Bladerunner I was a bit concerned. The Director's Cut was the definitive article for me for 15 years or so, and after seeing what they did with the Star Wars A New Hope 2004 DVD release I was worried that one of my favourite films of all time was going to be ruined forever. Thankfully this wasn't the case, and for me the Final Cut, especially in Blu Ray format, is now THE definitive version. Nothing's actually cut from the '92 version, and as MarvMarble has said its more of a cleanup. But I think the few very small new scenes add to the whole neo-noir experience. The slight change of dialogue when Roy Batty meets Tyrell works so much better in my opinion, and much respect to Joanna Cassidy for having Ridley Scott fix the 'problem' with the Zhora death scene.

Re: Top 10 movie re-edits
Posted By etoh76 1 September 24, 2009 08:50:14 PM

And is it just me or does anyone else get a little bit teary when Marlon Brando does his final bit in the much superior Donner cut of Superman II? Dang, he's good...

Re: Top 10 movie re-edits
Posted By MediaOKra 1 September 25, 2009 02:48:09 PM

Come on you don't really think the Apocalypse Now Redux is anything resembling an improvement of the original?

Re: Top 10 movie re-edits
Posted By daniel_g 1 September 26, 2009 03:27:52 AM

I would have added the DC of Dark City. Reefer Sutherland's introductory voice-over is removed, so the ending is actually a surprise (for anyone who didn't see the original edit).
Post a Comment
 
Play it again. Matt...

Play it again. Matt...

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Broadband

Mobile Broadband

Compare over 100 mobile broadband & broadband deals online!

Mobile Phones

LG ArenaHTC Magic

Compare over 250 mobile phones &
52,000 deals!