Amazon.co.uk Widgets
Den of Geek

Do you dare dislike Blade Runner?

Simon Brew


The sci-fi equivalent of The Emperor's New Clothes

Could the visionary spectacle that is Blade Runner be, whisper it, not much cop? Or for Simon, is it simply time to die?

Published on May 11, 2007

Blade Runner is, undoubtedly, a hugely important and iconic piece of cinema. It’s visually both dazzling and visionary, has never quite been matched and deserves its place in the technical annals of film history.

Sadly, the first time I watched it was on a 14” portable televlsion, where I was left a little nonplussed by it all. Nonetheless, I did appreciate it was a big screen experience, and so I watched it again. On a 20”.

This, clearly, was not going to plan.

Then the Director’s Cut turned up. And with it, a cinematic reissuing for a film which, by this point I was determined to see on a big screen. I was equally determined to see what I was missing about the film itself that hadn’t clicked with me before.

The answer? Nothing. While the Director’s Cut undoubtedly improved the film, and while it looks quite brilliant up there on a big screen, the film itself remains a hollow shambles. A vacuum. And, if you put the technical issues to one side, a dull, dull film. The sci-fi equivalent of The Emperor’s New Clothes, if you will.

Over the years, I’ve been castigated for daring not to like Blade Runner. I must have an aversion to proper sci-fi (not true). I must hate Philip K Dick work (not true). I must have some kind of problem with Ridley Scott as a director (er, we’ll come to that in a minute). It seems it’s simply not possible that someone, by the end of it, was disinterested to the point of not caring whether Deckard was a replicant or not.

I’m not alien to the film’s qualities. Harrison Ford aside, I thought the performances were fine, and there were some nice scenes in there. I also appreciate that it’s a hugely influential film, and do believe it deserves respect for that.

But, and I’ve watched it again since, after four goes I just feel it doesn’t gel, is bogged down by its ideas, and fails to deliver as a piece of filmed entertainment. Harsh, perhaps, particularly because I always admire something ambitious that doesn’t quite work. It doesn’t mean I have to like it, though.

I even appreciate that it’s a fairly shallow argument I’m putting forward, that one person’s dull is another person’s favourite film. But few films I’ve been shouted at more for disliking than Blade Runner, and while I’d gladly admire the photography over and over, the chances of me attempting again to hunt for the genuine, well-rounded and strongly executed substance of the film are remote.

And let’s quickly deal with Ridley Scott. I’m not a mad fan of a lot of stuff, Alien aside, which I think is his best film by some distance. Thelma & Louise was okay, Gladiator was good, Black Hawk Down was atrociously dull, Hannibal was embarrassing, Matchstick Men disappointing, and G I Jane insulting. He doesn’t like my work, either.

But back to Blade Runner. Appreciating there’s an inevitable tidal wave of people about to tell me I’m wrong – again – there’s a comments option down at the bottom there.

I will be waiting…

Meanwhile, I’ll start work on why Terminator 2 is rubbish if you like?

 

Tags

Users Comments

Re: Do you dare dislike Blade Runner?
Posted By stuxmusic 1 May 13, 2007 01:22:22 PM

BLADE RUNNER IS SHIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIT. I should know, i've seen it like 10 times.

Re: Do you dare dislike Blade Runner?
Posted By simonbrew 1 May 13, 2007 03:41:06 PM

I am not alone? Really?

Re: Do you dare dislike Blade Runner?
Posted By twosheds 1 May 14, 2007 01:10:57 AM

Blade Runner, among other ambitions, attempts to capture the mysticism, tragedy and ironic sense of isolation underpinning life in post-industrial cities. In that it succeeds in conveying that atmosphere through dazzling visuals and a truly legendary soundtrack, it stands up there with Midnight Cowboy, Taxi Driver and Klute. Admittedly, it does not have the integrity of those films, and is in my opinion therefore a magnificent failure. But it does have something profound and moving to say about humanity, and the pacific conclusion of the Batty/Deckard battle is a legendary movie moment by now (you can even buy a plastic model kit of Batty dying with the pigeon in his hand!). I think there are actually two streams of influence emitting from Blade Runner: the poignant and dazzling art design and visual miasma of the film permeated art design in ads and movies ever after; but the heart of the film -Roy Batty's hopeless plight, which was also the heart of the very different novel on which Blade Runner is based- is what gives the film legs. Ultimately, BR clearly stands in a raft of films that were green-lighted (green-lit..?)because of the success of Star Wars, and the film's commercial sensibility and high-gloss ultimately detract from its finer points. Neither does the casting of Sean Young and Harrison Ford help - she was a fairly untalented 18 year-old and he was, as usual, as wooden as the Golden Hind (though he does 'physical pain' better than any other actor). If the production hadn't been held up for six months, Dustin Hoffman would have been Deckard and Blade Runner would have been a far better film, I think. To be continued in the office (Simon)... :)

Re: Do you dare dislike Blade Runner?
Posted By twosheds 1 May 14, 2007 01:11:33 AM

PS You might want to get the CMS developer to recognise carriage returns in these comments :)

Re: Do you dare dislike Blade Runner?
Posted By Maxwell 1 May 14, 2007 07:21:27 PM

I don't care, I loved this movie...even if it was entirely self indulgent. The only bit that annoys me is the scene at the end driving into the mountains, which makes no sense. If the countrywide looked like that why would anyone live in LA???? The fact it was footage shot for the Shining an tacked on makes it even more bizarre.

Re: Do you dare dislike Blade Runner?
Posted By Kempas 1 May 15, 2007 01:14:30 PM

I really liked Blade Runner. And I loved the game so much I bought it twice. Yep, that's the exent of my input.

Re: Do you dare dislike Blade Runner?
Posted By Kempas 1 May 15, 2007 01:14:53 PM

*extent (no edit option?)

Re: Do you dare dislike Blade Runner?
Posted By Robmac 1 May 15, 2007 02:22:45 PM

I actually really like it - but its taken a while. I saw it as a nipper and thought it was SLOW and boring. It was Sci_fi so therefore cool, but it wasnt it had no spaceships or aliens in it like Battle Beyond the Stars. However over time it sorted to start to 'sink'in. What it lacks for in epic space battle that I wanted as a kid was replaced by style and coolness and after a while it sort of hypnotised me to its slow pace, melodic and beautiful Vangelis soundtrack and Raymond Chandler like story. Sets, backgrounds and designs are beautiful and look like a William Gibson book come to life. Ridley Scotts grasp of visuals is fantastic and the 'Time' to Die' speach is perfect. However I can see why it was slated when it came out - its no Star Wars, which is what they were hoping, but is the exact oppostite film...the thinking mans sci-fi blockbuster.

Re: Do you dare dislike Blade Runner?
Posted By ChristianLett 1 May 15, 2007 02:40:28 PM

It's my favourite film of all time. It was the film that made me want to become a film maker (and I have). Oddly though, it's the only film I've ever walked out on. Not because I had a sudden realisation that it was rubbish (perish the thought!), but because the print was scratched to hell. It had clearly been used by a tramp to wipe his arse and then bought from a car boot sale. Warner Village (Star City), hang your heads in shame!

Re: Do you dare dislike Blade Runner?
Posted By optim 1 January 7, 2008 07:35:24 AM

I cant believe someone else doesnt like Blade runner. In my opinion if you wana do a film noir well then look a touch of evil or chinatown. I dont mind slow films sympathy for mr venegeance is a slow film but it interested me where as this film plain bores me. Battlestar galactica contains so much drama and that works on so many more levels then is she isnt she or an android/cylon. Fuck BLAde Runner
Post a Comment
 
Harrison Ford in Blade Runner Blade Runner. All fur coat, but underwear lacking?

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Broadband

Mobile Broadband

Compare over 100 mobile broadband & broadband deals online!

Mobile Phones

LG ArenaHTC Magic

Compare over 250 mobile phones &
52,000 deals!