Amazon.co.uk Widgets
Den of Geek

Alternate Cover: Too Many Hulks

James Hunt


Can we have a Hulk comic that actually has the original character in it please?

Published on Aug 3, 2009

There's something wrong with the Hulk. As a line of comics, I mean. And no, this isn't just an anti-Loeb rant - although I'd be lying if I said I was enjoying his work on the title. The single problem with the Hulk ‘family' of books, however, can be easily summed up in one phrase:

There is no comic featuring The Hulk.

I spoke recently about the lack of jumping on points. This applies here. If someone wanders into a comic shop wanting to buy a Hulk comic - regardless of how interested they are in the industry - they will probably know very little about the character. What they will know is that, generally, Bruce Banner turns into the Hulk when he gets angry, and that he's big and green. Unfortunately, this isn't reflected in any of the Hulk's comics right now!

The Hulk family of books currently consists of the following characters and titles:

Red Hulk - Hulk
Jeph Loeb's flagship title has seen the Green Hulk replaced by ‘Rulk' in a storyline of astonishingly poor quality. Rulk's real identity has been kept secret for over a year now, and despite the fact that multiple stories have been given over to people trying to find it out, no official word has been given. Although Rulk spent a fair amount of time trying to kill the Green Hulk in his first appearance, a recent issue saw him spontaneously drain the ‘Hulk' out of Banner, leaving him defenceless, but alive. It's not really clear why.

Skaar - Incredible Hulk
The recently re-launched Incredible Hulk series resumes its numbering from #600 (despite the fact that #600 was, by all accounts, the #599th issue...) but rather than feature the real Hulk, it features his son, Skaar, who was conceived on an alien world and recently made it to Earth. The character is basically a Hulk/Conan mash-up with added Star Trek, and frankly, that's confusing enough without making him the lead in his father's book.

Hiro-Kala - Son Of Hulk
13 issues in, the series that used to be called Skaar: Son Of Hulk was re-named Son Of Hulk and features a new character, who appears to be the brother of Skaar - although no-one's really mentioned or noticed this before. It's not especially clear what's going on in this book, but one thing is certain - if people who've been reading it for 12 issues are left scratching their heads, it won't make an easy read for newcomers.

Lyra - Savage She-Hulk
Lyra is yet another of Hulk's children, this time from an alternate future where she was created as a test-tube baby, merging the DNA of The Hulk and the Femizonion warrior, Thundra. Although Lyra is the second character to bear the She-Hulk name, there are actually two others - Jen Walters, the original She-Hulk, and a new, Red version of She-Hulk who - surprise surprise - hasn't had her identity revealed.

So, there are two Hulk titles, neither of which have the Hulk in them. Two different characters both claiming to be the son of the Hulk, one of which has replaced the other in his book. And three different characters all independently claiming to be the She-Hulk.

As far as franchises go, it's not unfair to call it a complete mess. New readers will be confused. Old readers will be swamped with uninteresting new characters who bear no worthwhile relation to the characters they like. Ironically, one of Hulk's most famous catchphrases should perhaps be adopted as his new marketing strategy. Say it with me: Hulk just want to be left alone.

James writes Alternate Cover every Monday at Den Of Geek. His previous column can be found here.

 

Tags

Users Comments

Re: Alternate Cover: Too Many Hulks
Posted By DigitalMonkeyBoy 1 August 3, 2009 10:03:44 AM

I so agree with this. One very disgruntled Hulk fan here. The Rulk title is a travesty - there is no resolution to any plot points from Planet Hulk, slugfest after slugfest, poor Rick has been turned into some silly monster side-kick and why is Samson behaving so out of character? The whole line is a mess. Where there was once a really Incredible title and a Sensational She-Hulk, we now have a mess. But then this is similar across Marvel titles as a whole....Avengers this that and the other, Wolverine and Spiderman in EVERYTHING and great titles like Captain Britain cancelled. Make mine...DC!

Re: Alternate Cover: Too Many Hulks
Posted By DavidFullam 1 August 3, 2009 10:11:47 PM

Where is the Gamma Corps in all of this? I mean they were a big (and in my opinion, a very interesting) part of WW Hulk. Unless Marvel is planning to swerve us, I take it that Red Hulk is going to be the late Glenn Talbot? Grey's reason for joining Gamma Corps was to avenge his brother (Glenn)). So are they going to make an appearance or what? Wish they hadn't been forgotten.

Re: Alternate Cover: Too Many Hulks
Posted By Kardwell 1 August 5, 2009 03:57:30 PM

"Too many dicks on the dancefloor".

Re: Alternate Cover: Too Many Hulks
Posted By RobGordon23 1 August 10, 2009 09:05:03 PM

Funny you should mention no jumping on points. I went in to my local store and decided to pick up a Hulk book since i hadn't read it for a few years. After not understanding any of the recent issues, I thought i should maybe pick up a collection then instead, only to find the only collection that seems to be in stock is World War Hulk...which was also confusing to someone who's been out of the Hulk loop for some time. When did Marvel begin to disregard newcomers or return readers? They only seem to care about the readers who've haven't missed in an issue since, oh about 2000. This article is not something to help get back into the series either. Time for a new marketing strategy Marvel.

Re: Alternate Cover: Too Many Hulks
Posted By FrenkyA9 1 August 19, 2009 06:02:27 PM

Mr. comic book writer, don't make me angry. You wouldn't like me when I'm angry...
Post a Comment
 

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Broadband

Mobile Broadband

Compare over 100 mobile broadband & broadband deals online!

Mobile Phones

LG ArenaHTC Magic

Compare over 250 mobile phones &
52,000 deals!